Tuesday, November 17, 2026

The Crook Takes Visa — How AI Makes a Fake Store Look Safe Enough to Pay

 


AI gave holiday crooks a storefront. You’re about to give them a Christmas bonus. Open the retailer’s official app and make the deal prove itself. If the deal can’t survive a trip to the real store, let it die in your inbox.

Picture me on the couch, looking for blenders that cost $249 at Best Buy. An ad on my phone offers the same blender for $79. The logo looks right, the reviews sound real, and a red clock gives me 4 minutes to buy.

“Only 3 left,” the ad says.

Of course there are. A fake store never runs out of the exact thing a fool is about to pay for. I close the ad and open the Best Buy app. If I see the deal there, I’ll buy it there. If I can’t verify it, the crook can sell those imaginary blenders to somebody else.

For years, I could spot a lot of scam emails by the way they mangled the language or got the company’s name wrong. That was a decent test when the crook had to write the pitch himself. In December 2024, the FBI warned that criminals were using generative AI to produce convincing material faster, clean up errors that used to give them away, and run fraud schemes on a larger scale. Now the thief can send me a polished email with a warm holiday greeting and a return policy that sounds fair. I can admire the grammar all the way to the moment my card gets charged.

The crooks opened early for Black Friday in 2025. NordVPN found that fake eBay sites detected by its security tools jumped 525% in October from September, while fake Amazon sites rose 232%. That tells me how fast the copycats showed up in NordVPN’s data. The figures leave open how many of those sites used AI and how many took anybody’s money. But October is the part I’d circle. The fake shops were setting up while I was still buying Halloween candy. If I wait until Thanksgiving to get suspicious, I’ve already given the thieves a month’s head start.

I also don’t buy the idea that this is a problem for grandparents who need help opening a PDF. In a 2025 Pew Research Center survey, 42% of U.S. adults ages 18 to 29 said they had bought something online that turned out to be counterfeit or never arrived and they got no refund. Among adults 65 and older, the figure was 26%. Those percentages describe what people in each age group said had happened to them at some point. A young shopper can be quick enough to buy a jacket in 20 seconds. That still leaves 20 seconds for a liar to sell it.

The Federal Trade Commission saw plenty of those sales in the first half of 2023. Shopping made up 44% of the fraud reports involving a financial loss that started on social media. In 61% of reported shopping losses that began there, the merchandise never arrived. Clothing and electronics were among the most common no-shows. That’s the part I think about when the fraud numbers start to sound like background noise. Somebody paid for a winter coat. Somebody checked the porch every night. The only thing that arrived on time was the charge.

The ugly joke is that real retailers spent years teaching me to shop exactly the way a crook wants me to. Everything is a flash sale. Somebody in Ohio just bought the last toaster. The cart is about to expire, as if the blender needs to catch a flight. A thief can buy an ad on the same platform, use the same tools to reach people by age or interests, and make the same noise. The FTC has documented that too. I can see why the scam fits right in. By the time the phony store starts yelling “Hurry,” the real stores have already trained me to reach for my card.

So when a Facebook ad offers me a $300 mixer for $89, I open the retailer’s official app or type the store’s address myself. I search for the exact model because a cheap look-alike is its own little hustle. If I’m on a marketplace, I check the seller’s name and who takes the return. If the ad claims there’s a special code and I can’t confirm it through the store, I let somebody else chase it. Yes, I might miss a real sale. I’ve missed sales before. I’ve never had to call my bank to dispute a bargain I walked away from.

The same trick works after the purchase, when I’m tired of checking whether the package has shipped. Suppose a text says my delivery is on hold and asks for $1.99. “It’s two bucks,” I can hear myself saying. The thief is happy to let me think that’s what we’re discussing. The checkout form wants my card number, my billing address, and the security code on the back. Suddenly, that $1.99 has a long tail. I open my order history and check the tracking from there. If the message tells me to scan a QR code to get my package, it can sit there and look pretty.

If I’ve already handed over my card details, I call the issuer using the number on the card and tell them exactly what happened. I keep the receipt, the emails, and screenshots of the order. If I gave the fake store a password I use elsewhere, I change it on those accounts too. The FTC recommends paying by credit card when possible because I can dispute a charge for goods I never received. A seller who insists I pay for a blender with a gift card can keep the blender. I’m already dealing with enough fiction at checkout.

The most honest moment in Morgan Wright’s interview came when the host admitted he’d clicked a link and wondered whether the stuff he’d ordered would show up. I liked that moment because it lasted about as long as the gap between confidence and regret. One minute he was discussing scam victims. The next minute he was thinking about his own package. I know that feeling. I want it to hit while my card is still in my pocket, when I can open the official app, look up the item, and settle the question before I spend a dime.

I don’t need to figure out whether AI wrote the email, who built the site, or how many of those glowing reviews came from people with a pulse. I need to know who’s taking my money. The retailer’s own website or app gives me a way to check the deal without following the stranger who shoved it under my nose. That costs me a few seconds, which is precisely what the thief is betting I won’t spend. So I let the red clock hit zero. If a crook wants a Christmas bonus, he can ask his boss. He’s getting nothing from me.

 

Enjoyed this brief analysis? Explore my “Brief BookSeries”  for clear, provocative books on history, politics, AI, technology, and modern life. Available on Barnes & Noble, Amazon, Walmart, and Google Books

No comments:

Post a Comment

The Crook Takes Visa — How AI Makes a Fake Store Look Safe Enough to Pay

  AI gave holiday crooks a storefront. You’re about to give them a Christmas bonus. Open the retailer’s official app and make the deal prove...