Zohran Mamdani’s “New York for All” means poverty for everyone—grand speeches, empty shelves, and a city trading ambition for dependency. Socialism doesn’t feed the hungry; it just starves them equally.
Socialism always starts with speeches that sound like
gospel and ends with stores that look like ghost towns. Every socialist before
Zohran Kwame Mamdani has promised heaven and delivered hunger. And now, as he
prepares his campaign for New York City’s mayoral throne, I can already smell
the smoke—not from progress, but from a city about to burn its last loaf of
bread in the name of equality. His plan to turn New York into a socialist
paradise sounds noble until you remember that every socialist paradise has
always needed a ration book.
Mamdani’s promises are as sweet as a bakery window—free
housing, free healthcare, free everything. But behind that glass is an empty
shelf. He wants to give everyone a bigger piece of the pie without realizing
that someone still has to bake it. You can’t tax the baker, scare away the
farmer, and expect the oven to keep running. That’s not governance—it’s
economic suicide with a smile.
History doesn’t whisper its lessons; it screams them.
Every country that tried Mamdani’s brand of politics ended up with empty
wallets and full prisons. The Soviet Union promised equality and instead
produced breadlines longer than Broadway. Venezuela sang songs of fairness and
ended up printing money that wasn’t worth the paper. Cuba tried to feed
everyone and ended up feeding no one. Yet here comes Mamdani, promising to
repeat their mistakes with a Brooklyn accent and a designer suit.
He says he’ll make the rich pay their “fair share.” I’ve
heard that line before. It’s the same lullaby that drove businesses out of New
York in the 1970s, when taxes soared, crime exploded, and the city went
bankrupt. You can’t run a city by punishing productivity. You can’t grow an
economy by making success a crime. When the people who create wealth start
fleeing to Florida, New York will have nothing left but slogans, speeches, and
socialist graffiti.
Socialism is always loudest before it goes silent. It
shouts about fairness, then whispers about shortages. It parades in the streets
for equality, then hides behind ration cards. It kills competition by calling
it compassion. Mamdani’s speeches sound revolutionary, but revolutions built on
envy always end with chains. He wants to “redistribute wealth,” which is just a
fancy way of saying he’ll take from the builders and give to the bureaucrats.
The city will not become fairer—it will just become poorer, slower, and duller.
Mamdani and his followers like to point to Scandinavia as
proof that socialism works. But they forget that Sweden and Denmark aren’t
socialist at all—they’re capitalist countries with welfare systems funded by
booming private sectors. They build wealth before they share it. Mamdani wants
to skip the building part and jump straight to the sharing. That’s like
throwing a dinner party before cooking the meal. It’s not generosity—it’s
delusion.
The heart of socialism is control. It wraps itself in the
language of care, but underneath beats the pulse of power. Once the government
decides what’s “fair,” it also decides who deserves what—and who doesn’t. It
starts by controlling rent, then wages, then production, then speech. Before
you know it, even dreams are regulated. And in a city like New York, where
ambition is oxygen, socialism would suffocate everything that makes it breathe.
Imagine it: a city where landlords can’t afford
maintenance because rent is frozen, where hospitals run out of supplies because
prices are capped, where small businesses die under taxes dressed up as
“justice.” The subways will still run, of course—but they’ll be packed not with
workers heading to jobs, but with citizens heading to government offices to beg
for their next subsidy. The city that once never slept will be kept awake by
hunger and bureaucracy.
The tragedy is that Mamdani doesn’t see this coming. He
believes the problem is greed, when in truth, it’s dependence. New York’s
greatness was built by people who came with nothing and worked their way up,
not by those who waited for City Hall to hand them a miracle. The American
dream doesn’t need a middleman; it needs freedom. Mamdani’s vision of a
state-managed utopia would turn that dream into a government job application.
Socialism has always been the politics of envy—an
ideology that punishes success and rewards complaint. It thrives on resentment,
not results. It’s a system where everyone is equal because everyone is equally
miserable. When Mamdani says he wants “justice,” what he really means is
control. When he says “the people,” he means “the party.” When he says “free,”
he means “paid for by someone else until they’re broke.”
New York has survived mayors who taxed, banned, and
overregulated, but it has never survived a full-blown socialist experiment. If
Mamdani wins, that experiment begins. Investors will leave, jobs will vanish,
and soon the city’s spirit—the raw, unapologetic ambition that made it the
capital of the world—will fade into political propaganda. The lights of Times
Square will still glow, but the people who once powered them will be too busy
standing in line for free milk.
And when the collapse comes, Mamdani’s supporters will
say it wasn’t “true socialism,” just like every other apologist before them.
They’ll say it failed because it wasn’t radical enough, because it was
corrupted by greed, because the system wasn’t pure. But we’ll know better.
We’ve seen this movie too many times. It ends the same way every time: with
empty shelves, broken promises, and leaders who vanish when the bread runs out.
So yes, socialism begins with grand speeches and ends
with ration cards. It begins with applause and ends with excuses. Mamdani’s
campaign is a rerun of a failed ideology with a new cast and better marketing.
If he wins, New York will not become the city of dreams—it will become the city
of debts. And when the baker closes shop, the people will learn too late that
equality without productivity is just poverty with better slogans.
When the pie is baked by bureaucrats, everyone goes
hungry—and the only thing left to share is regret.
No comments:
Post a Comment